If you're in the business of real estate, you already know how quickly insurance premiums can eat into returns. Whether it's a first duplex or a twelfth door, insurance isn't just a line item — it's a lever. Most investors are pulling it the wrong way. Here's how to fix that.
Bundle Like a Boss
Holding multiple properties under separate policies with different carriers leaves money on the table. Consolidating under one master landlord or commercial property policy typically saves 15-30% in premiums, cuts down administrative headaches, and gives more leverage with the carrier — the right broker can get every property under one roof without sacrificing coverage.
Coverage That Actually Covers
Most investors don't find out they're underinsured until after the fire, flood, or lawsuit. Audit the policy for: Actual Cash Value vs. Replacement Cost (one pays for what the property was worth, the other for what it costs to rebuild), Loss of Rents Coverage (does the policy pay out if tenants have to vacate), and liability limits — especially relevant when tenants have guests on the property. The fine print is where profits quietly disappear.
Strategic Deductibles
Large deductibles intimidate newer investors, but for those sitting on healthy reserves who want a policy that responds to major events — not small claims — raising the deductible can mean real savings, often in the 20-40% range on premium. What's given up in coverage for minor incidents is gained in meaningful long-term savings.
The broker matters as much as the policy
An insurance broker working with investors should understand ROI and DSCR, not just coverage limits — someone who's never thought about how a property cash-flows isn't going to structure a policy that protects returns the way an investor needs it to.
Growing a rental portfolio?
I work with investors on consolidating policies and structuring coverage that actually protects returns — reach out and I'll walk through what fits your portfolio.
Get a Quote →